Compare your options
Buy vs. Rent Calculator
Compare the estimated costs of buying and renting over your chosen timeframe.
Your numbers. Your next step.
Compare the cost of buying and renting.
Choose how long you plan to stay, then enter your rental and purchase assumptions. Select Calculate Comparison to compare renting with buying and selling at the end of that period.
Planning comparison only. Results depend on your assumptions and do not predict market performance or determine which choice is right for you.
Beyond the monthly payment
Understand your buy vs. rent comparison.
Compare costs over your selected stay, including a home sale at the end. Explore how rental costs, ownership spending, and sale assumptions shape the result.
Time & rental costs
Renting’s total includes rent and renters insurance over your selected stay. Annual rent change applies after the first year; renters insurance stays constant.
Your comparison period applies to both scenarios and sets the assumed sale date. This tool compares the period you choose; it does not find the exact year buying overtakes renting.
Cash paid before sale
Buyer cash paid includes your down payment, purchase closing costs, mortgage payments, and entered property taxes, homeowners insurance, HOA fees, maintenance, and mortgage insurance throughout the stay.
The loan uses your fixed interest rate and term. Other ownership costs stay constant, including mortgage insurance; cancellation is not calculated. Enter annual taxes, homeowners insurance, and maintenance, but monthly HOA fees and mortgage insurance.
Sale proceeds & net cost
Future sale price uses your annual home value-change assumption. Selling costs and the remaining mortgage balance are deducted to find net sale proceeds. Buying’s net cost is buyer cash paid minus those proceeds.
The headline shows the absolute cost difference; its caption identifies the lower-cost option. Negative sale proceeds mean additional cash is needed at sale. A negative buying net cost means modeled proceeds exceed cash paid, not a guaranteed profit.
Compare one change at a time. Note both modeled costs and which option is lower. Adjust one input, then select Calculate Comparison again. Reset example restores the starting inputs and clears every result.
Investment returns on cash, tax effects, moving costs, utilities, and unentered expenses are excluded. Results depend on your assumptions and do not predict market performance or determine which choice is right for you.
A little more clarity
Questions about buying versus renting?
Clear answers about the comparison period, sale assumptions, and the costs included in each scenario.
What does the estimated cost difference mean?
It is the absolute difference between total rent and renters insurance and buying’s net cost after a sale at the end of your selected period. The caption identifies which has the lower modeled cost. This is a comparison over the entire stay, not a monthly payment difference or a recommendation to buy or rent.
Does this calculate when buying breaks even?
No. This calculator compares the two scenarios at the end of the period you select: 3, 5, 7, or 10 years. It does not search for an exact break-even date. Change the comparison period and calculate again to see how a different length of stay affects the result.
Why can buying’s net cost be negative?
A negative net buying cost means the modeled sale proceeds, after selling costs and mortgage payoff, exceed the buyer cash paid during the comparison period.
It depends on your assumptions and is not guaranteed profit. Negative sale proceeds mean something different: additional cash would be needed to cover the modeled selling costs and mortgage payoff.
Which assumptions should I review carefully?
Rent and home value follow your annual change assumptions. Other entered costs stay constant, including taxes, insurance, maintenance, HOA fees, and mortgage insurance. Mortgage insurance cancellation is not modeled.
Investment returns on cash, tax effects, moving costs, utilities, and unentered expenses are excluded. Starting values are examples, not quotes or forecasts.
How do I update my comparison?
After changing your inputs, select Calculate Comparison. Results remain unchanged while you type and update only when the calculation passes validation.
Reset example restores the starting inputs and clears every result. Select Calculate Comparison to calculate again using the restored values.
YOUR NEXT MOVE STARTS HERE
Let’s Talk About Your Next Move.
Whether you’re buying, selling, renting, or investing, let’s talk about your priorities, your timing, and your real estate options in Nassau County.
Terin Dallas Century 21 Miller Elite

